The jevons paradox was postulated by english economist william stanley jevons in his 1865 book the coal question. Sep 01, 2011 efficiency is like motherhood and apple pie who could possibly be against it and why. This has subsequently been proved to apply not just to fossil fuels, but other resource use scenarios. The jevons paradox, which was first expressed in 1865 by william stanley jevons in relation to use of coal, states that an increase in efficiency in using a resource leads to increased use of that resource rather than to a reduction. An inquiry concerning the progress of the nation, and the probable exhaustion of our coal mines is a book that economist william stanley jevons wrote in 1865 to explore the implications of britains reliance on coal. Feb 09, 2016 a look at how as the efficiency of machines increase and they need less fuel to power them, but as a result the operating cost of each machine is cheaper so their use is more widespread so fuel.
The jevons paradox and the myth of resource efficiency. Jevons paradox in 1865 stanley jevons warned the british government that increases in the efficient mining and use of coal steam engines would lead to not less coal use but rather to more coal use. It made the case that economics as a science concerned with quantities is necessarily mathematical. On the jevons paradox, climate, and fighting defeatism. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. For some 150 years, technologies designed to reduce demands for a resource have been recognized as having the potential to actually cause increased consumption. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can reassess it.
The spector of jevons paradox it is an article of faith within the sustainability movement that resource efficiency improvement must be the main response to peak oil and climate change. But jevons paradox, which is really an expression of the law of unintended consequences, tells us that this will encourage developers to build more homes in suburban virginia and maryland, and more businesses will move into the d. This refers to a form of induced demand wherein efficiency improvements in the use of a resource causes increased consumption of the resource rather than a. That insight is associated, above all, with the great english economist william stanley jevons, who started worrying about energy conservation 150 years ago. William stanley jevons born on 1st september 1835 in liverpool, england departed on th august 1882 in sussex, england studied in university college london and owens college university of manchester influenced by jeremy bentham british philosopher, jurist, and social reformer. Such unintended consequences need not be destiny and can be prevented. William stanley jevons 18351882 was an economist and philosopher who foreshadowed several developments of the 20th century. So a new energy policy framework should be established considering both. The jevons paradox tells us that improvements in fuel efficiency can lead to more consumption of fuel, and its logic goes beyond tougher vehicleemissions standards.
The phenomenon is called jevons paradox, after british economist, william stanley jevons who first documented it. If it were true, jevons paradox would have profound implications for sustainability. Efficiency is like motherhood and apple pie who could possibly be against it and why. Ecological marxists have also addressed the assumptions found in jevons paradox foster, clark and york, 2010. Accordingly, an analysis of the implications of the jevons paradox must abandon the realm of reductionism and deal with the complexity inherent in the issue of sustainability. In sum, jevons establishes growth of population, agricultural and manufactured goods, and coal consumption alongside higher economy or productivity. Jevons paradox is little known outside a few academic circles. The curse of energy efficiency, better known as the jevons paradox the idea that increased energy and materialresource efficiency leads not to conservation but increased usewas first raised by. Jevons paradox has been listed as one of the social sciences and society good articles under the good article criteria. Paul clarke, january 29, 2015 efficiency is the watchword of progress. There is a substantial literature on jevons paradox, and since the mid1970s, this term has been relabeled as the rebound effect ie. People will leave their cars at home and take the new train service. The return of the jevons paradox j o h n b e l l a m y f o s t e r, b r e t t c l a r k. The cost of steampowered coal extraction became cheaper and.
Aug 24, 2010 that insight is associated, above all, with the great english economist william stanley jevons, who started worrying about energy conservation 150 years ago. Jevons reply to mundella also reemphasized cairnes thesis that the cost of production was not the cause, but the effect of the efficiency of production 1878, p. Jevons paradox wikipedia economics the proposition that technological progress that increases the efficiency with which a resource is used tends to increase rather than decrease the rate of consumption of that resource. The jevons paradox william stanley jevons 2001 1865, one of the foundational writers in ecological economics, in his famous book the coal questionidentified what is perhaps the most widely known paradox in ecological economics, a paradox which has subsequently become known as the jevons paradox clark and foster 2001. William stanley jevons noted in 1885 that when coal burning got more efficient, people burned more coal. Download citation jevons paradox in the coal question william stanley jevons jevons, w. The jevons paradox and the myth of resource efficiency improvements john m. Jevons paradox is the observation that improved energy efficiency can increase the overall consumption of energy by making an activity cheaper and thus more scalable or accessible. Watch out for this energy paradox in your quest for self. Jevons paradox collapse of industrial civilization. If the quantity of coal used in a blastfurnace, for instance, be diminished in comparison.
If it were true, jevons paradox would have profound implications for. The curse of energy efficiency, better known as the jevons paradoxthe idea that increased energy and materialresource efficiency leads not to conservation but increased usewas first raised by. That increased energy efficiency will save us has become an article of faith. Heres what you can do to keep this idea in mind as you make your purchasing decisions.
Like many in my generation, ive been worried about global warming since i was young. Energy efficiency policies and the jevons paradox 71 a consideration of all these aspects could lead to a reformulation of the national energy policy. Policy actions are necessary to support efficiency, but additional actions are also required to control the rebound effect. The term jevons paradox flags the need to consider the different hierarchical scales at which a system under analysis changes its identity in response to an innovation. By studying the effects of steam engine innovations made by engineers such as thomas newcomen and james watt, he found that the increases in efficiency that they created actually increased consumption of coal rather than decreasing it, as it became more. The jevons paradox was discovered in 1865 by british economist william stanley jevons.
The recurring mantra in our culture is that technological silver bullets will save the day. In sum, jevons establishes growth of population, agricultural and manufactured goods, and coal. Jevons observed that englands consumption of coal soared after james watt introduced the watt steam engine, which greatly improved the efficiency of the coalfired steam engine from thomas newcomens earlier design. We have been taught to believe that an efficient process is better than an inefficient one. The rebound effect re is an umbrella term for a range of mechanisms that reduce the energy savings from improved energy efficiency. If youre looking for a free download links of the jevons paradox and the myth of resource efficiency improvements earthscan research editions pdf, epub, docx and torrent then this site is not for you. Jevons paradox in 1865 stanley jevons warned the british government that increases in the efficient. Rebound, backfire, and the jevons paradox increasing energy efficiency is the driving force for growing global energy consumption and carbon dioxide emissions this sounds like nonsense. Jevons suggested that as technological innovations progress, the rate of. The jevons paradox and the economy of drone strikes.
This came up before somewhere in this thread, but a newer version of jevon s paradox exists known as the khazzoombrookes postulate. There is considerable debate about the connections between efficiency and levels of resource consumption, particularly about the jevons. Revisiting jevons paradox with system dynamics systemic causes and potential cures rachel freeman, mike yearworth, and chris preist summary this article examines the dynamic relationship between the consumption of goods and services, technological ef. Frontiers unraveling the complexity of the jevons paradox. For example, doubling the efficiency of food production. Polimeni, kozo mayumi, mario giampietro and blake alcott london sterling, va. Last year, congress passed the energy independence and security act of 2007. Energy blackouts, while rare, occur and will likely happen more often as. Physical basis explains key components determining whether civilization can innovate itself toward faster economic growth through new energy reserve discovery, improvements to human and infrastructure longevity, and more energy efficient resource. A look at how as the efficiency of machines increase and they need less fuel to power them, but as a result the operating cost of each machine. Jevons was emphatic that energy efficient steam engines had accelerated britains consumption of coal. Download the jevons paradox and the myth of resource. Sep 14, 2009 william stanley jevons noted in 1885 that when coal burning got more efficient, people burned more coal.
Discuss research and forecasts regarding hydrocarbon depletion. However, the result is of prime importance, especially in current times. Watch out for this energy paradox in your quest for selfreliance. If the quantity of coal used in a blastfurnace, for.
William stanley jevons stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. I was introduced to the concept as a college student in the early 90s, years before climate change began making daily headlines. By studying the effects of steam engine innovations made by engineers such as thomas newcomen and james watt, he found that the increases in efficiency that they created actually increased consumption of coal rather than decreasing it, as it became more economical for people to run them and thus more steam. Garretts latest paper longrun evolution of the global economy. Sep 26, 2017 this refers to a form of induced demand wherein efficiency improvements in the use of a resource causes increased consumption of the resource rather than a decrease in its use.
Always consider whether the resources youre buying are made with renewable resources or not. Given that coal was a finite, nonrenewable energy resource, jevons raised the question of sustainability. English writer george orwell as the birthright of freeborn. The idea is generally derided by economists today but first discussion of the principle came from william stanley jevons in 1865.
The jevons paradox was first described by the english economist william stanley jevons in his 1865 book the coal question. Jevons paradox and the myth of technological liberation. Since the seminal work of stanley jevons the coal question, the problem of the rebound effect has repeatedly appeared in energy policy debates, challenging the consensus that improved energy efficiency will reduce energy use and carbon emissions and. Nov 05, 2014 william stanley jevons he published general mathematical theory of political economy in 1862, outlining the marginal utility theory of value admirable contribution to marginal revolution in the 19th century got public recognition on a large scale for his theory the jevons paradox the jevons effect 5. Citizens around the world have to deal with the problems related to pollution. The evidence for backfire from improved energy efficiency article in energy policy 374. The jevons dilemma, a paradox theorized during britains industrial revolution, illustrates how the drone programs greatest advantage its precision might lead policymakers into an inadvertent blunder. Im glad to see it starting to come up here in the green building community now, too. Thus was born jevons paradox, the idea that increased energy efficiency while. The curse of energy efficiency, better known as the jevons paradoxthe idea. I feel like i have come to terms with jevons paradox.
1015 517 1414 1355 79 915 1303 195 758 960 1382 27 1086 1244 1064 959 716 569 68 1391 248 1399 1416 1475 485 461 1305 682 85 238 1327 877 1250 169 962 1014 1116 669 593 788 416